Performance Reviews Cheat Sheet

Navigate performance reviews — self-assessment, gathering evidence, framing accomplishments, receiving feedback, and turning reviews into promotions.

Last Updated: July 15, 2025

The Brag Document

CategoryWhat to Track
ProjectsWhat you built, launched, or shipped — with impact metrics
CollaborationTeams helped, code reviews, onboarding, mentoring
GrowthNew skills learned, talks given, blog posts, certifications
PraisePositive feedback from peers, managers, customers — copy-paste into doc

Self-Assessment Framework

SectionContent
Accomplishments3-5 key wins with evidence — STAR format: Situation, Task, Action, Result
Areas for Growth1-2 honest gaps + what you're doing about them — shows self-awareness
Goals (Next Cycle)3 specific, measurable goals aligned with team/company priorities
Support NeededWhat you need from your manager to reach those goals

Receiving Tough Feedback

1. Listen fully
Don't interrupt or defend — take notes. Process before responding
2. Ask clarifying
"Can you share a specific example?" "What would success look like?"
3. Acknowledge
"I hear you — that's helpful feedback. Let me think about how to address it"
4. Follow up
In 2 weeks: "Here's what I've changed based on your feedback — am I on track?"
Pro Tip: Keep a 'brag document' year-round — a running list of wins, praise, and impact. When review season comes, you won't have to remember what you did 8 months ago.
Part of the Empire Builder Network